What works better? Neutrogena, St. Ives, or Proactiv?

I have the Neutrogena Oil-Free Acne Stress Control, St. Ives Blackhead and Blemish Apricot Scrub, and Proactiv.





I've been using Proactiv for a while now and it's worked like a year or so ago but now it doesn't work so much.





I've switched to Neutrogena last night and it looks like it just brought my bumps up to the surface. I have pimples all over my face and I've had it for a while since puberty began. Looking for a face cleanser that WON'T ruin my face anymore like proactiv did.What works better? Neutrogena, St. Ives, or Proactiv?
i've been usin proactiv for 1 year but it doesn't work....byeWhat works better? Neutrogena, St. Ives, or Proactiv?
i like most netruogena skincare products. they work well on me. i have the oil-free acne cream cleanser, oil-free spf moisturizer, toner, scrub, and acne spot treatment.





i heard proactive doesnt work that well and st. ives is okay. i have sued ti before
st. ives!


neutregena over dries ur skin. it ruined my face! i got so many zits from it!


st. ives is working fine on me


i havent used proactiv b4, but lots of ppl say it works...i was planning on getting it, but im having doubts..
Out of those, Neutrogena works best, while not drying out your face.


But if you want to use proactiv, then get a good moisturizer to use, so it doesn't dry out your face. =)





Such as Velocity moisturizer by mary kay (they also have a cleanser)


http://www.marykay.com/skincare//velocit鈥?/a>
Proactive is the best because it is long term.
proactiv works alot but if you stop using it then you will find a lot of pimples
clearisil aultra...(sorry if i spelled it wrong)but yea!!it works good for me!!! its been working ever since i got it...which was like....a coupe months ago...it works and it keeps it away!
I like neutrogena, but not the stress control stuff. Try the Clear Pore mask/cleanser and Oil-Free Acne Wash.


St. Ives is also really good and i love the apricot scrub!





Never tried proactiv.





Also the neutrogena On-the-Spot acne treatment works reallly well on pimples and zits.
First I would try Proactive and if that doesn't work try Neutrogena.
Proactive most definitely works better. There aree three cycles of acne , not just one, so at certain times your skin will definitely tend to reak out more. But go with the flow and STICK WITH PROACTIVE! neutrogina has scented ingredients ni it whci will triggerr acnee from the harmone secretion glands WITHIN your pores and actually worsen acne! therefore, girl, STICK WTHI PROACTIVE. there are great ingredients within it that soothe the skin and doo honestlyy clear iup acne. be patient and dontt mix products ever! doing that will make your face a complete MESS!! kk goodluck lovelyy%26lt;333333333333
ProActiv is the only thing that will work long term. You may need to see a dermatologist and get a prescription medication for your skin, like differin. Seeing a skin doctor will let you find out what is causing your skin problems, and what you can do to minimize problem zits and get clear skin.
proactiv i would say works pretty well but my dermatologist swears by neutrogena and i do too. it works sooo well but u have to consistently use it, it isnt like u use it once and you will have magical perfect skin like some people think you can do.